African-American
satire has been alive at least since the first black slave made fun of
her putative masters and their manners. In that moment of mockery, the
cakewalk was born, but this parody had a catch: The slave owners loved
it. They mistook the dance for a poor imitation rather than a dark
mirror. One of the first homegrown national fads to go global, the
cakewalk anticipated the paroxysms of twerking that would follow, whose
late adopters like Miley Cyrus might be forgiven for missing the deep
irony in the form’s black origins.
In
print, black satire made its way into the 20th century through works
like Langston Hughes’s “The Ways of White Folks” (especially the
transcendent story “Slave on the Block”), George Schuyler’s “Black No
More” and much of the folk tales and tomfoolery recorded and recast by
Zora Neale Hurston during the Harlem Renaissance.
There
were those who saw this satire without the least bit of humor. Richard
Wright’s scathing attack on Hurston as a retrograde writer set a pattern
not of discourse but of dismissal. It would take the 1960s, the
reckonings of the Black Arts movement and the efforts of Alice Walker to
reappraise Hurston — and to elevate satire as a form of protest. Cecil
Brown took up Hurston’s folk humor in fiction and nonfiction (one of
his books featured, for good measure, a giant black middle finger); Mel
Watkins would go on to write a definitive book on black humor; and
Charles Wright, the author of the 1960s novel “The Wig,” became a cult
hero to those who like their racial romps postmodern and Flip
Wilson-funny. In the end, it turned out that everyone just wanted to be
Richard Pryor.
Into
this rich tradition Crip-walks Paul Beatty. First known as a poet and
whom audiences back in the day might know from a classic MTV poem spot,
he has written three other comic novels and edited the terrific “Hokum:
An Anthology of African-American Humor,” whose cover boasts a
watermelon slice in lieu of a smile. All that should be a tip-off that
Beatty is interested in skewering the popular (or at least cutting it
into bite-size slices). On MTV, he essentially recited a Your Mama joke.
“The
Sellout” is more a Your Daddy joke. At its heart (if satire can be said
to have one) is the narrator’s relationship with his dead father; with
his father’s cronies and frenemies; and ultimately with Dickens, his Los
Angeles hood that has been “disappeared”: “There was no loud send-off.
Dickens didn’t go out with a bang like Nagasaki, Sodom and Gomorrah and
my dad” (killed by police). This tragedy is milked for comedy, in the
tradition of the blues, and Dickens takes on a character much like the
novel itself — borderless, outrageous, filled with crazy characters we
are not so much meant to believe as be bombarded by.
The
book opens with a prologue, which takes the beginning of Ellison’s
“Invisible Man” (“I am an invisible man. No, not some spook. . . . ”)
and spoofs it beyond belief, taking decades of stereotypical characters
and putting them on display in the Supreme Court. In those hallowed
halls, the narrator sparks up some weed before his attorney Hampton
Fiske argues the case in broad comedy daylight. (Our narrator has been
charged with trying to reinstate slavery in his home and segregation in a
local middle school.)
I
thought often of the 1990s appointment TV “In Living Color” when
reading the novel; Beatty takes the same delight in tearing down the
sacred, not so much airing dirty laundry as soiling it in front of you.
“The Sellout” isn’t a book for the fainthearted — though not exactly for
the lighthearted either.
From
the prologue the book turns to Dickens, “an agrarian ghetto,” where
folks raise livestock and the narrator’s sociologist father raises him
as a race experiment (“40 acres and a fool”). Stereotypes tap-dance
along until we get to Hominy Jenkins, “the last surviving member of the
Little Rascals.” In his desperate search for recognition (it would seem
he was always on the cutting room floor), Hominy becomes less holy fool —
like Eddie Murphy’s Buckwheat on “S.N.L.” in the 1980s — than unholy
terror. After the narrator saves Hominy’s low-fat bacon, Hominy pledges
himself to the narrator as his slave.
Indenture
serves as both parody and relief for Hominy: He offers himself as a
human footstool or stands stock still like a lawn jockey — after
enduring so much racism and mistreatment, it would seem, why not make it
literal? For Hominy’s birthday the narrator rewards him by
resegregating the Dickens city bus. (No wonder he jokingly calls himself
“the Kim Jong-un of ghetto conceptualism.”) The biggest joke is that
few notice the sign at first, and when finally a white person enters, it
turns out later she’s been hired by the narrator to provide Hominy the
pleasure of relinquishing his seat.
By
this point you have either made peace or war with the book’s style,
which, beyond the profane, becomes slightly predictable in its similes —
not in what is said exactly but in the way things are always three or
four other things. “Hominy is no source of pride: He’s a Living
National Embarrassment. A mark of shame on the African-American legacy,
something to be eradicated, stricken from the racial record, like the
hambone, Amos ’n’ Andy, Dave Chappelle’s meltdown and people who say
‘Valentime’s Day.’ ” There are more mentions of the N-word than on a
Sigma Alpha Epsilon field trip. But like early Richard Pryor, Beatty
seems to wish to take the word out of the shadows, or from those today
who euphemize it as “nigga,” as if pronunciation is destiny.
Or
is he merely trying to make an American classic, like “Adventures of
Huckleberry Finn,” which inspires some of the book’s most hilarious
passages? A member of the father’s group, the Dum Dum Donut
Intellectuals, has rewritten a version of “Huck Finn” in which he has
replaced “the repugnant ‘N-word’” with “warrior” and “slave” with
“dark-skinned volunteer.” The retitled book is “The Pejorative-Free
Adventures and Intellectual and Spiritual Journeys of African-American
Jim and His Young Protégé, White Brother Huckleberry Finn, as They Go
in Search of the Lost Black Family Unit.” (My favorite reworked classic
by this character, who becomes integral to the court case that frames
the book, may be “Measured Expectations.”)
In
the latter, more meditative half of the book, the narrator cautions
against being offended: “If I ever were to be offended, I wouldn’t
know what to do. If I’m sad, I cry. If I’m happy, I laugh. If I’m
offended, what do I do, state in a clear and sober voice that I’m
offended, then walk away in a huff so that I can write a letter to the
mayor?” From its title on, “The Sellout” so clearly and gleefully means
to offend that any offense taken suggests we aren’t as comfortable with
race or ourselves as we wish to be.
This
gap of course is where satire makes its home. If poetry, per Lucille
Clifton, means to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable,
satire says one out of two ain’t bad. “The Sellout” sometimes does this
not by being funny but by being too close for comfort. It remains so
outrageous, in fact, that you can’t even get comfortable with the
narrator, who will seemingly say anything. But do we recognize that he
is wearing “a mask from our own collections . . . the happy mask we
carry in our back pockets, and like bank robbers whip out when we want
to steal some privacy or make an emotional getaway?”
Beatty’s
novel breaks open the private jokes and secrets of blackness (one of
which is that Being Black Is Fun) in a way that feels powerful and
profane and that manages not to be escapist. In the book’s most
compelling sections, it starts to consider the sacrifices necessary for
survival: “We’re the black moths in that classic evolution photo,
clinging to the dark, soot-covered tree, invisible to our predators and
yet somehow still vulnerable. The job of the swarthy moth is to keep
the white moth occupied.”
Beneath
the proliferating references to the Marx Brothers and Abbott and
Costello lurks another book: one about California itself. This is,
we’re regularly reminded, a California story, one of prospecting and
migration and pain, set in that place old maps once depicted as cut off
from the mainland. “To this day, when the census form arrives in the
mail, under the ‘RACE’ question I check the box marked ‘Some other race’
and proudly write in ‘Californian,’ ” the narrator tells us. California
is a state of mind, in which the resegregation of a school might
somehow make the ballot as part of a progressive measure. The wildness
of this West feels especially fitting given how many of the best black
satirists, from Pryor to Ishmael Reed (who gets name-checked), have
made their home there.
Beatty’s
novel is a metaphorical multicultural pot almost too hot to touch.
There’s an interlude on the idea of “sister cities,” and near sublime
passages on surfing that offer up an alternative to the Dickensian
borders the narrator is intent on redrawing. But, of course, it’s the
all-black context — much as in Hurston’s real-life Eatonville, Fla., or
Colson Whitehead’s Sag Harbor — that emboldens Beatty’s fiction (and
the inside jokes).
In
the end, the novel reminded me of “Black Twitter.” For every “smdh” I
was “lmbao” — if you have to ask what these terms mean, maybe you
shouldn’t. If not a classic, “The Sellout” is destined to be a really
good cult jam. It’s a post-soul parody, trying to feel more like the
skits between songs than the song itself. And Beatty, a little like your
daddy’s radio, mostly skips hip-hop, reckoning more with life before
hip-hop went global. He tries instead to go back in time and do what
gangsta rap did in protesting oppression through its fantasia — using
farce instead of pretend force. These days, one might be mistaken for
the other — though not exactly forgiven.
Post a Comment